Rationale In Research Paper
Chapter 5 examines the implications of recommendations from earlier chapters for supporting infrastructure, both fi- Although many features of international data collection in educational research have changed over the past decade, at least one has not: research that provides comparative information across nations continues to expand understanding of education as a social and economic institution and provide rich sources of ideas about how nations can strengthen teaching and student achievement. These ideas range from methods for early childhood education (France, Germany, and Italy), a model for the structure of higher education (Germany), and goals for mass urban education (England), to the Suzuki method of teaching music (Japan).Holmes (1985) traces the earliest efforts to observe and learn from foreign education systems to Plato’s reference to Sparta in . reveal that on 19 academic tests American students were never first or second, and in comparison with other industrialized nations, were Nonetheless, by 1990, the president and the governors acknowledged the importance of international perspectives in formulating domestic education policy when they defined national education goals for the nation.The increasing scrutiny of earlier studies has revealed their limitations and the consequent need for improvement in the planning, execution, and dissemination of international comparative research….The lack of an adequate system of education indicators to inform education policy making has become increasingly apparent.Previously, there was a scarcity of data sufficiently robust to support valid cross-national comparisons; today, a glut of good-quality data overwhelms the field and remains largely unanalyzed, even as new follow-on surveys are launched. schools faced few mandated tests, and most were willing to participate in the occasional voluntary, internationally oriented tests; today, with increased requirements for mandatory testing, increasing numbers of schools are unwilling to add to their testing burden by participating in voluntary assessments.Previously, large-scale cross-national education surveys were initiated sporadically, every few years; however, between 19, data collection for at least one and as many as three surveys was scheduled annually. The infrastructure for conducting large-scale international studies that has developed over the past decade, which plays an important role in ensuring the quality of large-scale international education surveys, has become institutionalized, and the desire to keep this infrastructure engaged has played a role in decisions to support new and more frequent studies.tionship between the practice and desired outcomes in different settings.
Few new initiatives have been launched either to cull insight from ongoing nonsurvey-based international studies or to support systematic new ones attuned to independent research agenda. students are not first in the world in mathematics and science, educational rhetoric in the United States remains essentially one-dimensional, lacking the sense of rich possibilities that international perspectives can provide.
It is a triennial survey of the knowledge and skills of 15-year-olds in the principal industrialized countries. The purpose of this report—which is directed to federal sponsors of international comparative education research, domestic and international researchers, private foundations, and state and district officials who are eager to improve their part of the U. education system—is to lay out the rationale for such research; describe its scope, purpose, and potential impact; and make recommendations regarding future directions.
It assesses how far students have acquired some of the knowledge and skills that the study considers essential for full participation in society. to the persistence of an inwardly focused approach to education studies in the United States. Fundamentally, international comparative studies contribute to basic education research by documenting the existence of a much broader array of educational practices and outcomes than is available in the United States alone.
Indeed, there is an increasing concern that international assessments are now conducted more frequently than reforms can produce change in the U. education system, which may discourage ongoing, longer term reform efforts.
In addition, the results of large-scale domestic and international surveys are raising a host of questions that often are addressed best by smaller scale studies requiring a wide range of research methods, both qualitative and quantitative.